
Theatre L’Homme Dieu is wrapping up a phenomenal summer of live theatre and music with one of my favorite musicals: Once. The story, initially developed as a movie released in 2007, was adapted for the stage and received eight Tony Awards in 2012. Adapting musicals for the movie screen has been a popular trend; however, the outcomes are often met with mixed reviews. Movies like 2012’s Les Miserables were well-received by most audiences (with a Rotten Tomatoes score of 70%) and the November release of Wicked, starring Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande, is highly anticipated as a box-office hit; meanwhile, despite a cast with phenomenal star power, 2019’s production of Cats has been thoroughly mocked and even reviled (with a 19% score on the Tomatometer… ouch.) The reverse adaption of movies to musicals poses interesting challenges, ranging from condensing multiple settings to one stage set, often reducing the number of cast members, and conveying emotion without the benefit of close-ups and camera angles. Oh, and of course, everything is live and no two performances are the same.
Once is one of those rare stories which may actually play better on a stage than on the big screen, and the creative set design and lighting of TLHD’s production bring the city of Dublin to life. Whether it is a street corner, a bank office, a bridge, a bar, or another location, you know where the characters are. The best part? Because of the size of the theatre, you are there with them too, experiencing these crucial moments in their lives.




The story takes place over the course of only one week. We watch as two strangers- “Guy” and “Girl,” both musicians- meet. We witness their lives and talents interweaving in complicated and unforgettable ways, see glimpses of what has been and what could be, and then are returned to the reality that life is as exquisitely serendipitous as it is tragically complicated. You have to see the show to truly understand, and you will be better for having done so.
The music of Once serves as an expository device often reserved for dialogue. We learn that both Guy and Girl are separated from significant others and through the music they are sharing with each other, we understand the confusion, heartbreak, and passion associated with these relationships. Whether it’s Guy singing the lines “Ten years ago I fell in love with an Irish girl/ She took my heart/ But she went and screwed some guy that she knew/ And now I’m in Dublin with a broken heart” or Girl singing “Are you really here or am I dreaming/ I can’t tell dreams from truth/ For it’s been so long since I have seen you/ I can hardly remember your face anymore,” it is clear that these two characters are weighed down with baggage- and not just the Hoover (vacuum cleaner) that appears in multiple scenes.
Interestingly, despite the intimacy created by the set, lighting, dialogue, and music, you only know the characters by “Girl” and “Guy.” This is a sharp contrast to the season’s earlier production of tick, tick…BOOM!, Jonathan Larson’s autobiographical musical in which the lead character bore the name Jonathan. Other theatrical works are even named after their lead characters, from Annie and Dear Evan Hansen to Uncle Vanya and a whole lot of Shakespeare’s plays, to name a few. Other characters in Once have names, so why wouldn’t the main characters?
This is one of many paradoxes which define the relationship between the characters and between the characters and the audience. The music is raw and emotional, an open door to the inner turmoil of the characters; yet, they have just met and we have just met them as well. As audience members, we may project our own hopes for the romantic future of these two star-crossed characters, yet we only know what we are allowed to see in two hours. We witness the collision of two lives, two cultures, two worlds, and some of the hilarious and heartwarming situations in which they find themselves during their short time together. And then, as swiftly as we fell into the story, the show is over and, like the characters, we walk away cherishing the experience and memories of what happened… once.





